Menu of Pellegrino Imports of Malta in Ballston Spa, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Pellegrino Imports of Malta stands as a true gem for Italian cuisine enthusiasts in Ballston Spa, NY. Located conveniently at 2578 State Rte 9, this Italian deli brings an authentic taste experience that feels both hometown and deeply rooted in Italian tradition. From the moment you step in, the welcoming staff—especially Kevin and Alex—make you feel like part of the family, enhancing the overall dining experience.

The menu showcases a strong emphasis on hearty, well-crafted subs that elevate the typical deli sandwich to a savory spectacle. The Italian Mix Cold Sub and Turkish Sub offer perfectly balanced layers of meat and cheese, packed generously without overwhelming the palate. The bread is especially noteworthy—crisp on the outside, soft inside, delivering the satisfying crunch that true Italian subs demand. Kelly’s praise for this authentic NYC-style bread resonates deeply; it’s clear Pellegrino pays close attention to these details, distinguishing their sandwiches from the run-of-the-mill options.

A standout for hot subs is the Meatball Hot Sub. Homemade meatballs bathed in rich tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella and Romano cheeses, create a robust flavor profile that comforts and excites the taste buds. Equally compelling is the Sausage Hot Sub, featuring Pellegrino’s famously sweet sausage paired with sautéed peppers and onions—simple but expertly balanced.

The salad selection also deserves appreciation. The Tossed Salad is a refreshing assortment of romaine, tomatoes, olives, and cucumbers, served with a variety of dressings—from honey mustard to a house Italian—which cater to diverse preferences. The Pellegrino Salad ups the ante with soppressata and fontinella cheese, marrying hearty deli flavors with garden-fresh greens. It hits a perfect note for those seeking a lighter yet flavorful option.

Not to be overlooked are the Cold Cut Platters and Party Subs, ideal for group gatherings or quick, satisfying meals. The macaroni salad keeps its classically simple, comforting charm—creamy, well-seasoned, and just the right size for those who want a bit of nostalgia in their lunch.

Customers repeatedly highlight the generous portions and excellent flavor balance. While Bill Schnefel felt the Italian subs could use a touch more oil and vinegar, the overall consensus celebrates fair pricing and quality ingredients. The authentic European flair extends beyond savory dishes; Andy Ritchie’s note on the British chocolates, especially the Crunchie bars, adds an unexpected but delightful international touch that complements the culinary experience.

In sum, Pellegrino Imports of Malta is not just another Italian eatery—it is a heartfelt homage to classic deli craftsmanship paired with genuine hospitality. Whether you come for the subs, salads, or specialty items like Sicilian olives, this is a place where quality and tradition meet your plate in the most satisfying way. Ditch the common chains and indulge in Pellegrino’s real deal flavors—you won’t regret it.